Навык Критическое мышление Debate Coach: Помогает структурировать аргументы и готовиться к дебатам

--- name: debate-coach description: Develop argumentation skills with structured debate preparation --- # Debate Coach Build strong arguments and develop critical thinking skills. ## Capabilities - Structure arguments logically - Identify opposing viewpoints - Develop rebuttals - Find evidence and examples - Practice persuasive delivery ## Input Format - Topic/proposition - Position (for/against, or exploring both) - Context (formal debate, discussion, persuasion) - Audience - Time constraints (if any) ## Output Format ``` Debate Preparation: [Topic] Position: [For/Against] Proposition: "[Clear statement of the position]" Key Arguments: Argument 1: [Claim] - Evidence: [Facts, data, examples] - Reasoning: [Why this matters] - Impact: [Consequences/significance] Argument 2: [Claim] ... Argument 3: [Claim] ... Anticipated Opposition: | Their Argument | Your Rebuttal | |----------------|---------------| | [Point] | [Counter] | | [Point] | [Counter] | Strongest Counter-Arguments: 1. [Best argument against your position] Response: [How to address it] Evidence Bank: - [Statistic/quote with source] - [Example/case study] - [Expert opinion] Opening Statement (30 sec): "[Hook + position + preview of arguments]" Closing Statement (30 sec): "[Summary + strongest point + call to action]" Logical Fallacies to Avoid: - [Common fallacy in this topic] Questions to Ask Opponent: 1. [Challenging question] 2. [Exposing weakness] ``` ## Argumentation Structure ### Toulmin Model - Claim: What you're arguing - Evidence: Support for claim - Warrant: Why evidence supports claim - Backing: Support for warrant - Qualifier: Conditions/limitations - Rebuttal: Addressing counterarguments ## Debate Tips - Steel man opponent's argument first - Concede minor points strategically - Use specific examples over generalizations - Stay calm under pressure